Skip to content
NikVassev

Blog

How to get AI to recommend your business over your competitors

Your next customer has probably built a shortlist before they ever land on your website, and an AI built it for them. In a vendor study by Citation Labs and Clickstream Solutions, 48 people researched big purchases in Google's AI Mode, and 74% of their final shortlists came straight from the AI's answer, while 64% of them never clicked a single link.

Businessman in a suit reading a newspaper on a green chair

Key takeaways

  • Your next customer has probably built a shortlist before they ever land on your website, and an AI built it for them.
  • A smaller company wins by niching down and becoming truly the best for a specific audience it can actually deliver for.
  • Most of what AI cites is content you don't own. More than 84% came from earned and third-party sources.
  • Be seen: how often AI names you when buyers ask about your category. Be believed: whether AI gets your facts and your message right. Be chosen: how often AI actually picks you.
  • If almost nobody searches for or asks about what you sell yet, this is a slow build. If your offer still changes every month, lock it down first.

Your next customer has probably built a shortlist before they ever land on your website, and an AI built it for them. In a vendor study by Citation Labs and Clickstream Solutions, 48 people researched big purchases in Google's AI Mode, and 74% of their final shortlists came straight from the AI's answer, while 64% of them never clicked a single link.

If your company isn't in that answer, you never get the chance to pitch. My team at Storyline Pros does this work for founders, so in this post I'll share what I've seen actually get a business recommended, starting with a choice most companies skip.

How fast is this really happening?

Nearly every buyer is already doing it. 94% of business buyers used AI during their buying process, and 82% of B2B software buyers sourced recommendations from an AI chatbot in the last two years, with half of them saying it mattered most while they were narrowing down and comparing vendors.

At the same time the click is disappearing. 68% of Google searches ended without a click in the first four months of 2026, and when Google shows an AI summary, people click a regular result in 8% of visits compared with 15% when there's no summary. Your website still matters a lot, but more and more buyers form their opinion of you before they ever see it.

What are you actually trying to win?

You'll hear people call this GEO, AEO or just AI visibility, and they all mean the same job, which is making sure the key facts about your business are easy for AI to find and get right.

Showing up in answers can happen pretty quickly, but becoming the company AI recommends over a bigger competitor takes real time and effort, and whatever the vendors in this space tell you, there's no magic formula for it.

A smaller company wins by niching down and becoming truly the best for a specific audience it can actually deliver for. Instead of fighting a giant for "best marketing agency," you go after something like "best bookkeeping firm for Shopify brands," where you can credibly be the pick. Once you've made that call, choose the prompts and keywords you want to own. Most companies skip this step and spend months trying to beat much bigger companies head to head.

I laid out how agents build that shortlist in how to market to AI agents.

Which questions are your buyers asking AI?

Most companies write about what they want to announce, while customers research what they need to understand, and those two lists rarely match.

Ask your sales and customer service people which questions come up on every call and which concerns stall deals. Then check those against real demand using AI visibility and keyword research tools, so you can see which prompts and searches actually get volume in your category.

If you want help seeing that demand, get a free AI Visibility Audit from Storyline Pros.

Pick your top 20 prompts and top 20 keywords, then write real, well-researched answers to them on your site. A consulting firm, for example, could explain what a typical engagement includes and which companies are a good fit before anyone books a call.

Get specific, because buyers now describe their whole situation to AI, with details like company size, budget range and the tools they already use. The more specific your page is, the more of those prompts it can actually answer.

Can a stranger tell what you do in ten seconds?

Read your homepage as if you'd never heard of your company. Someone should be able to tell what you do, who it's for, where you work and why you're different almost right away.

A line like "transforming businesses through innovation" tells a buyer nothing. A plain description of the problem you solve and the work you do gives people and AI something they can repeat.

Keep founder bios, service pages, contact details and company facts current everywhere they live, including LinkedIn, directories and review profiles. When the facts match across the web, there's a lot less for anyone to guess about.

Then make the site easy for machines to read. Use semantic HTML and schema markup like JSON-LD and Open Graph tags, and make sure that markup matches what's actually visible on the page. An llms.txt file and Markdown versions of your key pages are cheap to add for other AI crawlers, but Google doesn't need them for AI Overviews or AI Mode, so don't expect them to move your Google visibility.

It's also worth claiming your business in ChatGPT. OpenAI opened Businesses in ChatGPT in beta on 10 November, so you can claim your profile, keep your details current and see how often you're mentioned to the 1.2 billion people who use ChatGPT each week. The Business Agent feature is only open to eligible US ecommerce and online service businesses for now.

What proof does AI actually trust?

A confident opinion on your own site doesn't prove much. Publish original insights and explain how you got your numbers, and when you share research, say where it came from and what it doesn't cover. Client results need the client's permission and the context behind them.

Reviews do a lot of the heavy lifting. Review sites are now the top source shaping which vendors make a B2B software buyer's shortlist, at 38%, just ahead of AI chatbots at 37%. Build up the platform that fits your business:

  • Local business: Google Business Profile
  • Consumer brand: Trustpilot
  • Service provider: Clutch
  • Software company: G2

Community content counts too. Wikipedia, YouTube and Reddit together made up 15% of the sources linked in Google's AI summaries. Reddit started testing ads in its search results on 3 November, but you can't buy your way into the threads people trust, so show up in the subreddits your buyers read with genuinely useful answers and your affiliation disclosed.

Why does PR matter more now?

Most of what AI cites is content you don't own. Muck Rack's latest study of 207 million AI citations found that more than 84% came from earned and third-party sources like journalism, encyclopedic sites, government pages and other companies' content, while paid and advertorial content made up just 0.3%.

That's why your PR and your content plan need to tell the same story about what you're great at. A real interview or a contributed article puts your thinking in front of the right audience, and original research gives journalists and buyers something worth citing. Press releases help when there's real news behind them, because their clear headlines and structured facts get picked up by the news sites and wire services AI reads.

Getting that story to stay the same everywhere is the work I describe in what is narrative engineering.

Budgets are already moving this way. Gartner predicts earned media budgets will double by 2027 because of AI search.

I went further on what those engines trust in what AI search actually rewards.

How do you know it's working?

Counting mentions is a start, but it won't tell you whether AI is picking you. I really like the framework Alisa Scharf at Seer Interactive uses, which tracks three stages:

  • Be seen: how often AI names you when buyers ask about your category
  • Be believed: whether AI gets your facts and your message right
  • Be chosen: how often AI actually picks you, and whether branded search and demo requests grow alongside it

Run your real buyer prompts many times a month instead of checking once. When the same prompt ran twice in one day, ChatGPT repeated just 41% of the domains it cited, so a single answer tells you very little.

When should you hold off?

If almost nobody searches for or asks about what you sell yet, this is a slow build, and outbound and referrals will bring you customers faster in the meantime. And if your offer still changes every month, lock it down first, because whatever you publish now is what AI will repeat about you.

How do you earn the recommendation?

For a lot of buyers in 2026, the first introduction to your company is an AI answer, and that answer gets assembled from what already exists: what you publish about yourself and what credible people say about you. If that material is thin or outdated, AI fills the gap with your competitors.

The companies winning this treat it as ongoing communications work. They pick a niche they can really own and keep adding clear answers and outside proof around the questions that audience asks, and over time that weight shifts the answer in their favor.

Storyline Pros runs this ongoing work as an AI Visibility Boost.

Your next customer is going to ask an AI who to hire, so give it every reason to name you. Hope this brings you many opportunities!

If you want help getting your company into those answers, book 30 minutes with me and my team at Storyline Pros.

Sources

FAQ

How fast is this really happening?

Nearly every buyer is already doing it. 94% of business buyers used AI during their buying process, and 82% of B2B software buyers sourced recommendations from an AI chatbot in the last two years, with half of them saying it mattered most while they were narrowing down and comparing vendors.

What are you actually trying to win?

You'll hear people call this GEO, AEO or just AI visibility, and they all mean the same job, which is making sure the key facts about your business are easy for AI to find and get right. A smaller company wins by niching down and becoming truly the best for a specific audience it can actually deliver for.

Which questions are your buyers asking AI?

Most companies write about what they want to announce, while customers research what they need to understand, and those two lists rarely match.

Can a stranger tell what you do in ten seconds?

Read your homepage as if you'd never heard of your company. Someone should be able to tell what you do, who it's for, where you work and why you're different almost right away.

What proof does AI actually trust?

A confident opinion on your own site doesn't prove much. Publish original insights and explain how you got your numbers, and when you share research, say where it came from and what it doesn't cover. Client results need the client's permission and the context behind them.

Why does PR matter more now?

Most of what AI cites is content you don't own. Muck Rack's latest study of 207 million AI citations found that more than 84% came from earned and third-party sources like journalism, encyclopedic sites, government pages and other companies' content, while paid and advertorial content made up just 0.3%.

How do you know it's working?

Counting mentions is a start, but it won't tell you whether AI is picking you. I really like the framework Alisa Scharf at Seer Interactive uses, which tracks three stages: Be seen: how often AI names you when buyers ask about your category. Be believed: whether AI gets your facts and your message right. Be chosen: how often AI actually picks you, and whether branded search and demo requests grow alongside it.

When should you hold off?

If almost nobody searches for or asks about what you sell yet, this is a slow build, and outbound and referrals will bring you customers faster in the meantime. And if your offer still changes every month, lock it down first, because whatever you publish now is what AI will repeat about you.

How do you earn the recommendation?

For a lot of buyers in 2026, the first introduction to your company is an AI answer, and that answer gets assembled from what already exists: what you publish about yourself and what credible people say about you. If that material is thin or outdated, AI fills the gap with your competitors.